The movie in question was Kung Fu Panda. We were worried about this movie for two reasons: 1) It was longer than 15 minutes and 2) it had a scary subplot involving a snow leopard. Proving to us how much she's grown up, the length of the movie seemed to be of little consequence to her...but her fear of the danger that Kung Fu Panda and his friends encountered during the course of their journey was almost too much. She asked after the first "scary" scene, "Can I go home now?" And that quickly turned into "Can I leave?"
To paint a picture for you, Annika was sitting on Chris's lap for about 85% of the movie. Her little body is still too light for the 'old school' theater chairs, so she had to sit on one of us. During the height of her fear, I took her and cuddled her and promised her that it would be ok. She would settle for a bit, but then cry out in fear, "Please! I want to go home!"
It was too much for me to bear, so I told Chris that we needed to leave (having had earlier made the unholy parental pact of 'it's ok to leave if she freaks out even though we're wasting 40 bucks') and he shook his head. I said, "No..seriously." And he said, "No."
He went to the concession counter and purchased some "incentive." Every time the scary snow leopard came on screen, she was given a piece of candy. I thought it was genius...positive reinforcement to face her fears!
It was rightly pointed out to me later by a friend, "Yeah, now she'll turn to food whenever she needs comfort in the future."
Woops.